The Making of… Catching a Killer: The Search for Natalie Hemming

Erica Gornall & Jennifer Shaw
Shooting Producers

To find out the full story, watch ‘Catching a Killer: The Search for Natalie Hemming on Thursday June 1st, 9pm on Channel 4.

Erica Gornall  – The Police

img_7708
Erica filming on location

‘Get to Milton Keynes custody now. There’s a woman missing and her partner has been arrested.’ That call sparks a massive operation as the on call film rota kicks in and cars, cameras and people scramble. Most details are not given out- it is highly confidential, and there is no time. This is the life of the Major Crime Unit at Thames Valley Police – every minute counts and the police need to gather a team. I need to get to custody as soon as possible and any other information would need to come through as I’m driving. They can’t wait for us- if we are not there we miss it, simple as that.

Filming with the police means that you need to live their lives as much as possible. It turns out that the lifestyle of a detective here involves early starts, long adrenaline -fuelled hours into the next morning, a sporadic and sparse diet of anything that fits into a polystyrene box and working to the constant pressure of the clock. The ticking timer is the countdown to custody deadlines, tthe window to gather evidence, and the ability to charge.

For film-makers, who tend to be notoriously tardy with time, we had to acquire police discipline fast. When – early on-  we turned up 2 minutes late for a meeting (pretty good going!), we were not met with the waft of people arriving into a room. We were instead confronted with a massive team who got there at least 10 minutes early in order to start on the dot. Cue amused looks as we hurried to get set up. ‘This isn’t TV time,’ came the quip from across the room.

Lesson learnt. Time to join the team.

In this case, the interviewing officers Dale and Wendy welcomed me as they prepared to delve into the key evidence ahead of interviewing Paul Hemming. His partner Natalie had gone missing and no one had seen her since. After acting suspiciously with police, he was arrested.  Gaps had already started to appear in his story – his car had been seen out over the night his partner went missing and yet he insists he was in bed all night. The children heard a crashing sound. A rug had disappeared.

The interviewing officers let me into their world and discussed openly all of their thoughts. ‘This is dreadful’, exclaimed Wendy as she looked through a child’s statement and taking in the magnitude that these children had lost both parents overnight. But there is little time for reflection- minutes later, they are on their way down to see Paul and see what he has to say.

Given the tensions with Paul and the need for police to find Natalie, I held back filming in custody at these interview stages. I only took the decision to openly film when he was being charged and there was no more interviewing to be done.

With this intensity of filming and with something happening constantly, the real skill in filming this is to make quick decisions on what to film. By filming one thing you miss another. These moments can’t be filmed again. Any time not filming is spent talking to the officers and finding out quickly what is coming up next. Understandably, because they unfortunately investigate murders every day, it is common for them to come back from something you desperately wanted to capture and reveal they’ve just done that. The knack is to stay on top of developments or even plan ahead to see if something they see as routine, is actually really important and eye-opening for the viewer.

Dale, Wendy and I got on really well and I was given a good heads up. This was helped along with teas and sandwiches purchased in the moments of downtime. It sounds trivial but we all start work at 7am and during interviewing, there may not be a chance to eat or get anything before midnight. Cue the fast-food: the sustenance for the officers to push on through and find out as much as possible about where Natalie is when every minute counts.

The search for Natalie took weeks – and although it’s a case with a resolution, the reality on the ground as the days went by could not be more different. Each day was a different search in an area so vast it would have taken months to search the whole lot. It felt overwhelming and there was nothing to predict they would definitely find Natalie. Morale ebbed and flowed, but the drive continued – to the next field, the next piece of woodland, on and on.

It was the hottest weeks of the year, in claustrophobic sweaty scene suits, heavy equipment and searching rough terrain through thick woodland full of brambles. Me and the other filmers were there the whole time, experiencing the optimism, the challenges, the grit and the disappointments – all to find a woman who disappeared without a trace.

Jenni Shaw – The Family

IMG_7707
Jenni about to enter a scene

 

Friday 6th May. Bubbly 31yr old mum of three Natalie Hemming has been missing for five days.

In the Major Crime Unit, each new day brings a new and longer list of frantic actions. But for an ordinary family in Hemel, it’s a very different story: another sleepless night, another day of painful waiting.

“They’re such a lovely family” says Family Liaison Officer (FLO) Nikki Smith as she and colleague Natalie Golding drive me to mum Margaret’s house for the first time in their unmarked police car. Little did they or I know at that stage that I would more or less take up residence in the back of that Vauxhall estate over the coming weeks and months.

Despite being in this horrendous abyss, Natalie’s siblings had agreed to meet Anna Hall and I. On pulling up, Anna goes inside to introduce us and I wait anxiously in the car with my camera. We have no idea if we will be turned away.

Incredibly, after a few minutes of passionate explanation by Anna, they wave me in. The start of one of the toughest but most rewarding films I have worked on to date.

Although I’d been shooting the first few days of fast-paced police action using an EasyRig, we decided this might be a little overbearing for the first time I filmed. A CineSaddle, worn round my neck like a giant pillow, would have to do.

Natalie’s siblings had no idea what news the FLOs had come to deliver that day but they waited patiently in the living room until I was set up and ready to film. It turned out it wasn’t good news at all: this is no longer a Missing Person enquiry but a Murder. The kind of news no family should ever have to hear.

Despite this earth-shattering development, we were made to feel more than welcome. A constant stream of cups of tea and worried neighbours quickly indicated that this was a house always open to visitors- full of love and laughter.

We didn’t meet Natalie’s mum Margaret on that first visit – the disappearance of her youngest daughter was still sinking in. But as the search for Natalie stretched out from days to weeks, I would become one of the regular visitors to her family home. Cigarette in hand, she always greeted me with an affectionate hug and a smile, as the FLOs returned with more questions and more bad news.

But the worst news had not yet come. As the extensive search for Natalie continued, we as a team all knew that the inevitable could happen at anytime – we were on call day and night.

Finally, on the morning of Sunday 22nd May, the call came.

A young woman’s body had been found in a ditch on a country road near Watford. I knew immediately it had to be her. Now the Family Liaison Officers needed to go and deliver the news to Margaret.

Anna Hall and I had talked in advance about how I might film this moment if and when it did happen. Margaret had been incredibly generous in letting us film some very tough times but it was important for me not to overstep the mark at this shattering time. Our plan was for me to film at a distance through the window and roll for sound.

Unexpectedly, as I arrived with the FLOs and brother Sean on that fateful morning, Margaret was instead sat outside enjoying the rare sunshine. I knew what was coming but she didn’t. So as the FLOs Nikki and Natalie broke the news I hung back at the gate, wanting to give her some privacy behind the manicured rose bushes now fully in bloom.

She’s in our care now and we will look after her- we can finally bring her home to you”- says Nikki, crouched down and holding Margaret’s hand.

It hit home to me at that moment that Natalie was just a few months older than me when she went missing. No doubt she had similar hopes and dreams for a happy and fulfilled life. It’s hard not to take an investigation like this home with you.

It would have been much more difficult to reach the level of trust and openness required to capture these incredibly private and difficult moments without the support of the Family Liaison Officers. From the very first day, they embraced and passionately supported the motive for our film, becoming an advocate for us amongst family and friends and carefully facilitating contact right through to the trial.

More than anything, however, a film of this impact would never have been possible without the bravery and openness of Natalie’s family, courageously allowing us into their lives at the worst possible time.

That day when they first opened the door to us and every day after that- they made a choice. This was no longer just about them- it was about trying to prevent other families from ever having to go through that same pain and loss. To have been a witness to this was both an incredible responsibility and a privilege – one, which we as filmmakers should never take for granted.

To find out the full story, watch ‘Catching a Killer: The Search for Natalie Hemming on Thursday June 1st, 9pm on Channel 4.

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s